USA Today
"Right now it looks like one of the movies that will define its year even more than the KILL BILL duo did." 04/01/2005 p.7EChicago Sun-Times
"[I]t's like a comic book brought to life and pumped with steroids....It's a visualization of the pulp noir imagination, uncompromising and extreme. Yes, and brilliant." 04/01/2005 p.29 Entertainment Weekly
"[A] jazzy-looking screen translation..." 04/08/2005 p.44-45 Uncut
"Rodriguez delivers a sumptuous computer-generated vision of Miller's hardboiled fantasy universe....A perfect slice of gleefully violent 21st-century film noir for sick, twisted pop culture aficionados everywhere." 06/01/2005 p.136-137 Rolling Stone
"Credit first goes to Robert Rodriquez, a tirelessly innovative director who thrives on doing things the rules say he can't....A bold, uncompromised vision." 04/21/2005 p.123 Sight and Sound
"SIN CITY is consistently gorgeous..." 06/01/2005 p.73-74 Premiere
"This was a groundbreaking movie for both its look and how that look was achieved." 09/01/2005 p.119 Movieline's Hollywood Life
"Robert Rodriguez and Frank Miller's all-digital uber-noir gets a blowout DVD-ing..." 11/01/2005 p.104 Uncut
Ranked #10 in Uncut's Best Films Of 2005 -- "Rodriguez creates a visual masterpiece, an entirely digital rendition of the comic-book world." 01/01/0206 p.82-83 Rolling Stone
Ranked #5 in Rolling Stone's "Top 25 DVDs Of 2005' -- "[T]he film captures the dazzling monochrome of Frank Miller's graphic novels." 12/01/2005 p.92 | 
