Netgear ProSafe FVS318 VPN Firewall with 8-port Switch - 8 x 10/100Base-TX LAN, 1 x 10/100Base-TX WAN - FVS318NA

I purchased two of these to use between home and office. The performance is terrible. I spent lots of time with Tech Support. My Internet bandwidth speed was cut in half at both locations. Tech support says the reason is because every packet is examined. Thats fine but the processor in this model is not strong enough to keep up with my network. Now for the good news...Spend a little more and get the FVS338. What a difference...no loss of bandwidth at all. Also they just opened a US Clear Speaking Tech Support Center!! for the ProSafe products (Dec 2007). What an improvement! The VPN stays connected and works perfect. I am finally very Pleased..
 
Was this review helpful?    

The NETGEAR FVS318 is real nice heavy blue steel router, most impressive when you open the box. It goes down hill from there. I get 12 megabits per second when my cable modem is directly connected to my computer. Hook up the FVS318 and the speed is cut more than half. I called support, they backed up one version on the firmware, that did not help at all. They advised every packet is examined since its a firewall and hence the slow speed. I read several good things about the big brother FVS338. I ordered one and tested the speed today and there was no loss! Now I will proceed to setup my network. ADVISE....STAY AWAY FROM THE FVS318, SPEND THE EXTRA AND GET THE FVS338.
 
Was this review helpful?    

This is the first VPN Firewall I have tested. Its a big impressive metal case, it ends there. The first thing I noticed is a speed reduction over the internet. I get 8 megabits per second download from my ISP. That was verified on two separate websites with my computer hooked directly to my cable modem. After connecting the Netgear FVS318, my speed is cut over half (3.55megabits per second). Tech support told me this is the nature of a true hardware firewall as it inspects every packet hence the slowdown. I never made it to the VPN setup. I am sending back today after one day of ownership. The FVS338 is said to be much faster, I am ordering that for a spin. No way am I going to give up that much ISP bandwidth. The FVS338 has a faster processor so hopefully the performance will be better. Tech Support really is terrible but I have read enough to have some hope so I will roll the dice again.
 
Was this review helpful?    

When our old Netgear RT311 router needed to be replaced, I copied all the settings. The menu on the new one was more complicated and the terms were different enough that it took awhile to figure out how to set it up identically to minimize downtime. We haven't started using the VPN features yet, but wanted the capabilities for future use. So far we've been satisfied and haven't encountered any problems with the router.
 
Was this review helpful?    

I recently bought this router, and was looking forward to having 8 ports, IPSec/VPN pass-through, and an overall good experience, like I had with my RP614v1 (which did not have IPSec). It appeared to be fully functional, and continues to serve games, and is the heart of my home LAN. Against most port scan tests that NetGear recommends (Sygate, Symantec) it holds up very well. However, the FVS318 tucks tail and reboots in the middle of GRC's ShieldsUp portscan test (which was also recommended by NetGear). I thought it was an isolated event, but it unfailingly does so during that specific portscan. This is not to be expected from a business grade router, and represents a serious security flaw that must be disclosed and corrected. I have Rev 2 hardware, and firmware 2.4. It turns out that Rev 2 was a result of a component shortage, which makes me wonder what shortcuts may have been taken. There are discussions on DSLReports; just do a search on spontaneous reboot and FVS318. Am trying to work with NetGear support at the moment to see what can be done.
 
Was this review helpful?    

I bought the FVS318 to securely access a computer at a tiny company with no firewall from home. I was going to plug in the router in front of the work computer and just access it from the built-in windows XP VPN client from home. --but that's not how it works. The Appendix of the manual shows you how to connect the FVS318 to a windows box. ...But what they're doing is assuming you've got the FVS318 as your home firewall/router, and someone has decided to use this remote windows box as a VPN gateway. Makes sense. Its icky, but it does work. (do yourself a favor, when you see "secpol.msc", just type in 'mmc', and add in the security policy snap-in). But here's the real question. If Windows XP (mine is "Home") can be configured as a VPN server, and has a built-in firewall (with SP2), and Windows XP can also be a VPN client, why buy this box? Note: do a web search on how to configure a Windows box as a VPN server.
 
Was this review helpful?    

If you're a home networking enthusiast that has outgrown your Linksys 4 port cable/dsl router, then this is a good next stepping stone. This router offers a greater range of port forwarding and it uses a SPI (stateful packet inspection) firewall...aka, it actually looks inside each packet instead of just bouncing them around. So the firewall will stop code-red and other malicious code before it actually gets to your computer. Only problem I've had with it is that after a year it decided to stop forwarding DNS packets, but a firmware upgrade and a reset fixed that. Otherwise, its been flawless...whereas I'd have to cycle the power on my Linksys at least once a month.
 
Was this review helpful?    

The ease of use for the basic setup of the device is as most are these days, plug and play. The firewall function is not very configurable but it does provide for email notification of violations. The VPN function is another subject, particularly for remote access. Even with the VPN client software (costs more than a FVS318) that Netgear "supports" it is difficult to get up and running. The documentation for this functionallity is lacking and inaccurate. They did mention that it would work with the Win2K and XP built in VPN client but it was so difficult to configure that they have removed those documents from their website. Netgear support is HORRIBLE!! If you ask anything (other than how to spell Netgear) about this product bring your credit card along as they charge for tech support. If you have any doubts about these facts, check out http://www.tek-tips.com/ and search for FVS318. VPNs are complex by nature but this should not be this hard. Commercial gateways are not this difficult. If you are buying for the VPN (my primary reason) then consider this.
 
Was this review helpful?    

not only do they have the best tech support, the products they sell work very well.
 
Was this review helpful?    

Plug it in and turn it on, that's all there is to it. The web page based administration is very easy, the user manual covers everything if you feel the need to "RTFM". The only thing I did was change the admin password. The FVS318 is also supported by Port Magic so I don't even have to foreward any ports if I want to host a game and with UPnP support I think I can transfer files and run a web cam in msn Messenger (haven't tried yet). Security is tight with the FVS318, and the internal security log shows you exactly what is going on. Where security is concerned, this is just the begining of what you can do with this router. It feels VERY solid with its heavy metal case and all of the connectors are tight and secure. When you plug a cable in you know it's there to stay.
 
Was this review helpful?    

I almost got this router all configured and then I changed the admin password and I could no longer log in. Then I tried to reset to default settings and it started rebooting and nothing could stop it. I sent it back.
 
Was this review helpful?    

As a single unit, this box is awesome, full of features, and very easy to setup. I have two to create a REALLY hardened DMZ for my outward facing server. This configuration allows for only specified ports to be exposed, yet my internal network is also safe in case that system is compromised. All other systems are behind the second firewall/router.
 
Was this review helpful?    

This is the second time I have written a review on the FVS318. For some reason the first did not show up.I certainly hope BUY.COM does not limit reviews of this product to favorable reviews only. I purchased three Netgear FVS318As and installed the first one. The installation and configuration were easy. However, I was no longer able to access several web sites. Netgear support instructed me to turn off keyword blocking in the filter as that was causing problems. I was still unable to