Rolling Stone (p.65)
- 3.5 stars out of 5 -- "'This Ain't a Scene' is a bold single, complete with sampled drums and a Nineties R&B hookRolling Stone (p.116)
- Included in Rolling Stone's "50 Top Albums of the Year 2007" -- "Giant pop-rock songs with confectionery choruses..." Spin (p.81)
- 4 stars out of 5 -- "The band's brawny emo riffs and sugary hooks are still evident on songs like 'Hum Hallelujah,' but Wentz and Co. have beefed up their sound considerably..." Entertainment Weekly (p.71)
- "FOB's guitars still blare, and Stump has evolved into a superb frontman, with a voice that slides supplely from a bratty punk bark into a honeyed falsetto." -- Grade: A- Q (p.108)
- 4 stars out of 5 -- "Gleaming with instant hooks, this is a uniformly radio-friendly album. It's also a hugely addictive and likeable one" Uncut (p.79)
- 3 stars out of 5 -- "[I]t all adds up to a brave endeavour." Alternative Press (p.133)
- 4 stars out of 5 -- "Lyricist Pete Wentz breaks out of his usual first-person perspective without sacrificing any insight or honesty, and singer Patrick Stump delivers some of the band's most gut-wrenching and powerful melodies to date." Kerrang (Magazine)
(p.47)
- "[H]ere the musical brain behind the band gets to use the studio as his personal playroom, polishing and buffing the band's sound until it shines brightly enough for mainstream magpies." Kerrang (Magazine)
(p.70)
- Ranked #10 in Kerrang's "The Top 20 Albums Of 2007" -- "[T]his album will be a staple of radio rock playlists for years to come." Q (Magazine)
(p.74)
- Ranked #38 in Q's "The 50 Best Albums Of 2007" -- "[A] bold, gleaming pop album." | 
CD
5
4
